Devin Nunes' Re-Election Tests Whether All Politics Are Now National

Oct 29, 2018
Originally published on October 29, 2018 11:20 am

In 2016, Rep. Devin Nunes coasted to re-election by a double-digit margin. Now the eight-term Republican is in for the tightest race of his political life — all thanks to his views on the Russia investigations.

As chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, he has made himself a national figure for his staunch defense of President Trump and criticism of special counsel Robert Mueller, who's leading the investigation.

But Nunes' national profile is a double-edged sword: He has raised a tremendous amount of money, but it has also put a spotlight on him that he has never contended with before.

Polls taken in the past few months suggest Nunes could be ahead by as little as five to eight points. His challenger, Democrat Andrew Janz, has never before run for office but has raised more than $8 million, a staggering amount for a political newcomer in a heavily Republican district.

The big question in this race is whether a member of Congress can run primarily on national stature, while paying little attention to local issues.

A nationalized race

"He's made a decision he can pretty much do what he wants and ignore local concerns...if he just nationalizes this whole race," said Liz Mair, a Republican who runs the Swamp Accountability Project and is opposing Nunes as part of her organization's effort to protect Mueller's Russia investigation.

California grows half of the fruits, nuts and vegetables eaten in America, most of it grown in the state's Central Valley. In the district, constituents care deeply about agriculture, immigration and water — but Nunes has spent much of this past term in the House focused on criticizing Mueller and blocking additional investigations into President Trump's potential ties to Russia.

This has won Nunes a "Defender of Freedom" award from the American Conservative Union, a national organization. But the Mueller investigation isn't an issue that resonates locally among Nunes' supporters or detractors.

"The Russia issue is relevant insofar as it takes away the political capital that he has now in Washington to focus on what people care about here," said Janz, who says he's the one who can give local representation to the district. "I think that this race is about taking back the Central Valley."

"Like most districts, people are primarily concerned with their issues locally," said Michael Der Manouel Jr., a prominent Nunes supporter and local business leader. He says Nunes has been responsive to local agricultural and water issues — and to the region's farmers.

Nunes' actions as chair of the House Intelligence Committee have generated criticism that he is covering for the president and not conducting the panel's business in a bipartisan way. These controversies have helped nationalize what has typically been a sleepy race and led to an outpouring of donor dollars for both candidates from around the country.

While Janz has received about 28 percent of his support from outside his state, according to Open Secrets, Nunes has received more than half of the $11.6 million he's raised from outside California.

Mair, who lives in Virginia, received a fundraising appeal from Nunes' California congressional campaign, and provided NPR a copy.

It reads: "Your generous contribution from Virginia is exactly what I need right now to push back on the constant attacks from the radical left."

Limited availability for constituents

Meanwhile, Nunes has been hard to reach for his ordinary constituents. He has has not held a town hall since before the last election.

Even Der Manouel Jr., a staunch supporter, told NPR that he disagreed with this.

"I think that public officials should be accessible to their constituents. I know that personally he doesn't enjoy that environment much," he said in an interview in his Fresno-area office. "I think though that the hostility directed at him from around the country has made it a lot easier for him to say no to doing these."

Neither Nunes' campaign nor his congressional office responded to an interview request. And when NPR tried to visit his taxpayer-funded office in the most populated region of Nunes' district, it was closed and unstaffed at 2 p.m. on a weekday.

Phone calls to that office go straight to voicemail. The only other office in the district is more than 45 minutes away by car.

"One of the criticisms of his constituents have been: he is not accessible," said Lisa Bryant, a professor at Fresno State. She's a longtime political observer who works in the district. "I think if you are a loyal constituent and/or a donor to his campaign, he's accessible. He does fundraiser dinners and things like that. However, if as a regular constituent you want to go to his office and speak to somebody, a staffer in his office, it's very difficult."

The Fresno Bee reported that a recent meet and greet for supporters required guests to submit individual RSVPs indicating who invited them. Guests were also warned that no photos were allowed and that they could be subject to a personal search.

While he's not holding public events, he is blanketing the airwaves with attack ads — and even producing alternative media, such as his own podcast and his own website designed to look like a news outlet, "The California Republican."

Nunes has even picked a fight with the Fresno Bee, his local newspaper.

The Bee's editorial board declined to endorse him for the first time in 16 years after he declined to meet with them. In an unprecedented move, Nunes produced a 40-page, high-end, glossy magazine that suggests that the newspaper is after him because of its supposed communist sympathies, a maneuver endorsed by his supporters.

"I lived in the valley my whole life, except for six years. I stopped taking the paper this year," Der Manouel Jr said.

It's a unique strategy in this contentious midterm cycle. But to Nunes supporters all that matters is whether he is re-elected to Congress — not the margin.

"When you're in the House of Representatives there is only one definition of being hurt politically. And that is you are not re-elected," said Stephen Tootle, the vice chairman of the Republican Party in Tulare County, the more rural part of Nunes' district. "So I would say up to this point he has not been hurt politically."

But for the first time, Nunes faces a challenger who could make him sweat as the results come in on election night.

While he has traditionally coasted to victory, his views on Russia and the president may make for a nerve-wracking evening if a "Blue Wave" materializes.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

We go next to California's Central Valley. It's an agricultural region, the source of half the fruit, nuts and vegetables eaten in America, and also home to Congressman Devin Nunes. But ag policy is not what drives his national profile. The Republican who is seeking re-election is chairman of the House Intelligence Committee, known for his defense of President Trump and criticism of special counsel Robert Mueller. NPR's Tim Mak has more.

TIM MAK, BYLINE: In 2016, Devin Nunes won re-election by 35 percentage points. Now the eight-term Republican is in for the tightest race of his political life. Polls taken in the last few months suggest it could be a single-digit race.

LIZ MAIR: He's made a decision that he can pretty much do what he wants and ignore local concerns if he just nationalizes this whole race.

MAK: That's Liz Mair, a Republican who runs the Swamp Accountability Project and is opposing Nunes as part of her organization's effort to protect Mueller's Russia investigation. The big question in this race is whether a congressman can run primarily on national stature while paying little attention to local issues. His national profile is a double-edged sword. Though he's raised a tremendous amount of money, Nunes' unwavering support of Trump has put a spotlight on him that he's never had before. In the district, constituents care deeply about agriculture, immigration and water, but Nunes has spent much of his time focused on criticizing Mueller and blocking additional investigations into potential Trump-Russia ties.

ANDREW JANZ: The Russia issue is relevant insofar as it takes away the political capital that he has now in Washington to focus on what people care about here.

MAK: That's Nunes' opponent Andrew Janz, who says he's the one who can give local representation to the district.

JANZ: I think that this race is about taking back the Central Valley.

MAK: While Janz has received about 28 percent of his campaign funds from outside his state, according to Open Secrets, Nunes has received more than half of his money from outside California. Mair, who lives in Virginia, received a fundraising appeal from Nunes' California congressional campaign and provided NPR a copy.

MAIR: It reads, (reading) your generous contribution from Virginia is exactly what I need right now to push back on the constant attacks from the radical left.

MAK: Meanwhile, Nunes has also been hard to reach for his ordinary constituents. He has not held a town hall since before the last election. Even Michael Der Manouel Jr., a prominent Nunes supporter and a local business leader, told NPR that he disagreed with this.

MICHAEL DER MANOUEL JR.: I think public officials should be accessible to their constituents. I know he doesn't - personally he doesn't enjoy that environment much. I think, though, that the hostility directed at him from around the country has made it a lot easier for him to say no to doing these.

MAK: Neither Nunes' campaign nor his congressional office responded to an interview request. And when NPR tried to visit his taxpayer-funded office in the most populated region of his district, it was closed and unstaffed at 2 p.m. on a weekday. Phone calls to that office go straight to voicemail. The only other office in that district is a 45-minute drive away.

LISA BRYANT: And so one of the criticisms of constituents has been he is not accessible.

MAK: That's Lisa Bryant, a professor at Fresno State, which is in the district.

BRYANT: I think if you are a loyal constituent and/or a donor to his campaign that he's accessible. He does, you know, fundraiser dinners and things like that. However, if as a regular constituent you want to go to his office and speak to somebody - a staffer in his office, it's very difficult.

MAK: While he's not holding public events, he's blanketing the airwaves with attack ads and even producing alternative media.

(SOUNDBITE OF PODCAST, "THE DEVIN NUNES PODCAST")

DEVIN NUNES: Hi, I'm Devin Nunes, and welcome to my very first podcast.

MAK: Nunes has even picked a fight with his local newspaper, The Fresno Bee. The Bee's editorial board declined to endorse him for the first time in 16 years after he refused to meet with them. In an unprecedented move, Nunes produced a 40-page, high-end glossy magazine that suggests that the newspaper is after him because of their supposed communist sympathies. His supporters are with him on this. Here's Der Manouel again.

MANOUEL JR.: I mean, I've lived in this valley my whole life except for six years, OK? I stopped taking the paper this year.

MAK: It's a unique strategy in this contentious midterm cycle. So while Nunes has traditionally coasted to victory, his views on Russia and the president may make for a nerve-wracking election night if a blue wave materializes. Tim Mak, NPR News.

(SOUNDBITE OF LAKEY INSPIRED'S "STREET DREAMS") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.